Wydawnictwo
AWSGE
AWSGE
Akademia Nauk Stosowanych
WSGE
im. Alcide De Gasperi
WSGE
im. Alcide De Gasperi
BOOK CHAPTER (204-220)
Natural science arguments before (constitutional) courts in the Federal Republic of Germany, France and Costa Rica
KEYWORDS
ABSTRACT
The main thesis of the paper is that in restricting fundamental (public) health rights, the scientific reasoning should play a new, central role in the assessment of the conflict and the restrictiveness of fundamental rights (de lege ferenda). In this article we argue through some specific examples from the Federal Republic of Germany, France and Costa Rica, that the jurisprudence of European and many overseas constitutional courts (or courts of appeal) is infiltrated by scientific reasoning.
FUNDING
Projekt dofinansowany ze środków budżetu państwa, przyznanych przez Ministra Edukacji i Nauki w ramach Programu „Społeczna Odpowiedzialność Nauki II” pt. „Współczesny obraz społeczeństwa polskiego w nauce i debacie publicznej”
REFERENCES (29)
1.
Alexy, Robert: Constitutional Rights and Proportionality. Revus – Journal for Constitutional Theory and Philosophy of Law, (2014) 51–65. https://doi.org/10.4000/revus.....
2.
Bán-Forgács Nóra: Természettudományos érvelés az alkotmányjogban. Jogelméleti Szemle, (2023) 4. https://doi.org/10.59558/jesz.....
3.
Bán-Forgács Nóra: A rendszerváltás és az adatvédelmi ombudsman Magyarországon: Az adatvédelmi ombudsman alapjog-értelmezése. Budapest, L’Harmattan, 2021.
4.
Barak, Aharon: Proportionality stricto sensu (balancing). In: Bix, Brian – Spector, Horacio (eds.): Rights: Concepts and Contexts. London, Routledge, 2012a.
5.
Barak, Aharon: Proportionality, Constitutional Rights and their Limitations. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2012b. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO978....
6.
Bongiovanni, Giorgo – Sartor, Giovanni – Valentini, Chiara (eds.): Reasonableness and Law.
8.
Engle, Eric: The History of the General Principle of Proportionality: An Overview. Dartmouth Law Lournal, (2012).
9.
Florczak-Wątor, Monika ; Fruzsina, Gárdos-Orosz ; Malíř, Jan ; Steuer, Max, States of emergency and fundamental rights in books and in action, In: Monika, Florczak-Wątor.
10.
Fruzsina, Gárdos-Orosz; Jan, Malíř; Max, Steuer (szerk.) States of Emergency and Human Rights Protection : The Theory and Practice of the Visegrad Countries, Abingdon, Egyesült Királyság / Anglia : Routledge of Taylor and Francis Group (2024) 292 p. pp. 1-14. , 14 p.
11.
Gárdos-Orosz, Fruzsina, Constitutional review in COVID-19 crisis management in Hungary, In: Baraggia, Antonia (szerk.) Ustava na robu izrednega stanja : zbornik ob trideseti obletnici Ustave Republike Slovenije : s posebno zbirko esejev v angleškem jeziku Covid-19 and the Constitution (Covid-19 in ustava), Ljubljana, Szlovénia : Univerza v Ljubljani, Pravna fakulteta (2024) 476 p. pp. 380-399. , 20 p.
12.
Gárdos-Orosz, Fruzsina, Poszt-COVID: ami velünk maradt, a különleges jogrend, In: Bán-Forgács, Nóra; Lőrincz, Viktor Olivér; Mezei, Kitti; Szentgáli-Tóth, Boldizsár (szerk.) Poszt-COVID : A Covid-19 hatásai a jogrendszerre, Budapest, Magyarország : Akadémiai Kiadó (2024).
13.
Gárdos-Orosz, Fruzsina, The normative standards of human rights protection in normalcy and in emergency in Hungary, In: Monika, Florczak-Wątor; Fruzsina, Gárdos-Orosz; Jan, Malíř; Max, Steuer (szerk.) States of Emergency and Human Rights Protection : The Theory and Practice of the Visegrad Countries, Abingdon, Egyesült Királyság / Anglia : Routledge of Taylor and Francis Group (2024) 292 p. pp. 124-144. , 21 p.
14.
Gravagna, Katie – Becker, Andy – Valeris-Chacin, Robert – Mohammed, Inari – Tambe, Sailee – Awan, Fareed A. – Toomey, Traci L. – Basta, Nicole E.: Global assessment of national mandatory vaccination policies and consequences of non-compliance. Vaccine, (2020) 49: 7865–7873. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vacc....
15.
Győrfi Tamás: A többségi döntés tartalmi korlátai és az alkotmánybíráskodás. In: Jakab András – Körösényi András (szerk.): Alkotmányozás Magyarországon és máshol. Budapest, Új Mandátum Könyvkiadó, 2012. 33–57.
16.
Győrfi Tamás: Jogi érveléselmélet. In: Jakab András – Könczöl Miklós – Menyhárd Attila – Sulyok Gábor (szerk.): Internetes Jogtudományi Enciklopédia (Jogbölcselet rovat, Rovatszerkesztő: Szabó Miklós, Jakab András) http://ijoten.hu/szocikk/jogi-... (2021).
17.
Hungler, S ; Gárdos-Orosz, F; Rácz, L, Legal Response to Covid-19: V-VI, In: King, J; Ferraz, O (szerk.) The Oxford Compendium of National Legal Responses to Covid-19, Oxford, Egyesült Királyság / Anglia : Oxford University Press (2021) 113 p. p. on-line Paper: e40 , 62 p.
18.
Hungler, Sára: Compulsory Vaccination and Fundamental Human Rights in the World of Work. Studia Iuridica Lublinensia, (2022) 1: 63–77.
19.
Huscroft, Grant – Miller, Bradley W. – Webber, Grégoire (eds.): Proportionality and the Rule of Law, Rights, Justification, Reasoning. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2014. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO978....
20.
Huscroft, Grant (ed.): Proportionality and the Rule of Law Rights, Justification, Reasoning. Western University Press, 2014. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO978....
21.
Katsoni, Spyridoula: What Does the Vavřička Judgement Tell Us About the Compatibility of Compulsory COVID-19 Vaccinations with the ECHR? Völkerrechtsblog, 21 April 2021, doi: 10.17176/20210421-100920-0.
22.
Kecső, Gábor ; Szentgáli-Tóth, Boldizsár ; Bettina, Bor, Emergency Regulations Entailing a Special Case of Norm Collision. Revisiting the Constitutional Review of Special Legal Order in the Wake of the COVID-19 Pandemic, JURIDICAL TRIBUNE 14. : 1 pp. 5-26. , 22 p. (2024).
23.
Pap, András ; Lőrincz, Viktor Olivér ; Kovács Szitkay, EszterPandémia, közpolitika, jog: diskurzív és szakpolitikai összefüggések. In: Gárdos-Orosz, Fruzsina; Lőrincz, Viktor Olivér (szerk.) Jogi diagnózisok II. : A Covid 19 világjárvány hatásai a jogrendszerre. Budapest, Magyarország : L’Harmattan Kiadó (2022) 491 p. pp. 383-407. , 25 p.
24.
Peters, Anne: A plea for proportionality: A reply to Yun-chien Chang and Xin Dai. I-CON, (2021) 3: 1135–1145.
25.
Petersen, Niels: Alexy and the »German« Model of Proportionality: Why the Theory of Constitutional Rights Does Not Provide a Representative Reconstruction of the Proportionality Test. German Law Journal, (2020) 2: 163–173. https://doi.org/10.1017/glj.20....
26.
Pablo, R.: When the Center Lies Outside the Figure: Republic, Imbalance of Powers and Emergencies in José María Serna De La Garza (coordinator), Covid-19 and Constitutional Law (Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México, 2020) 33-40. 41.
27.
Kovács K.: Hungary’s Struggle: In a Permanent State of Exception, VerfBlog, 2016/3/17, verfassungsblog.de/hungarys-struggle-in-a-permanent-state-of-exception/. 30.
28.
Lagi, S. (2020), State and Sovereinty: Some reflections on Hermann Heller as interpreter of the Weimar crisis, Cahiers d’Agora: revue en humanité, n°3 (ISSN 2608 – 9157).
29.
Lebret, A.: COVID-19 pandemic and derogation to human rights. Journal of Law and the Biosciences, vol 7. ed. 1. 2020. 32.
We process personal data collected when visiting the website. The function of obtaining information about users and their behavior is carried out by voluntarily entered information in forms and saving cookies in end devices. Data, including cookies, are used to provide services, improve the user experience and to analyze the traffic in accordance with the Privacy policy. Data are also collected and processed by Google Analytics tool (more).
You can change cookies settings in your browser. Restricted use of cookies in the browser configuration may affect some functionalities of the website.
You can change cookies settings in your browser. Restricted use of cookies in the browser configuration may affect some functionalities of the website.
